Oh boy,
This is a GT86 forum what do you think the answer is going to be?
Ask this queation on pistonheads or such like if you want an unbiased opinion.
But since you are asking... buy a GT86, it's better because I said so
Beacuse of my age i can't test drive them. I was all up for the c class and gti. Then i started to think.
The c class is just for comfort and that's all, not full to drive The gti is a all rounder but where I live its associated with drug dealers. That what put me off it and because of that insurance is really high
Then i seen the gt86 i dont know why but something about this car made me fall in love with it. From the outside it got the looks. To me looks 10x better then the c class and gti. Inside not so much but i can do things to improve it.
Its not technology advanced like the other two.
What am looking in a car is a car that is fun to drive, but that also has good looks and and easy to live with.